PLAB 2 History Taking: Mastering the Fatigue Station
Few PLAB 2 stations unsettle candidates quite like tiredness. The symptom is vague, the differential is enormous, and the temptation is to fire off hundreds of closed questions before the eight minutes vanish. Yet fatigue stations are among the most predictable stations in the exam — if you walk in with a framework. This guide gives you that framework: how the station is marked, exactly what to ask, the red flags you cannot miss, what to tell the examiner, and how to close safely with time to spare.
Why the Fatigue Station Keeps Appearing
Tiredness is one of the commonest reasons patients book a UK GP appointment, which is exactly why it appears so often under the Assessment of presentations section of the GMC blueprint. A fatigue station quietly tests every marking domain at once:
Data gathering — can you turn an ambiguous symptom into a structured, system-based history?
Clinical management — can you generate a prioritised differential, choose rational investigations and build a safe plan?
Interpersonal skills — can you do all of this with empathy, plain English and shared decision-making?
It also lets examiners bury sensitive topics — low mood, alcohol, pregnancy, weight loss — inside an apparently innocent presentation. Gently uncovering these is what separates a safe doctor from a question-asking machine.
The Format: What Happens in Those 8 Minutes
PLAB 2 is a 16-station OSCE. Each station lasts 8 minutes, preceded by 2 minutes of reading time. Expect one of two formats:
History-taking format — you take the history, then the examiner asks one or two structured questions (typically your differential diagnosis and your investigations).
Consultation format — a fuller encounter in which you must explain your thinking, agree a plan and safety-net before leaving.
Prepare for both. Many candidates lose marks not in the history itself, but in a rambling answer to the closing examiner questions.
How You Are Marked
| PLAB 2 domain | What it means in a fatigue station |
|---|---|
| Data gathering, technical and assessment skills | Open-to-closed questioning, systematic screen, red flags, ICE (ideas, concerns, expectations) |
| Clinical management skills | Prioritised differentials, targeted investigations, safety-netting, follow-up |
| Interpersonal skills | Listening without interruption, empathy, jargon-free explanation |
Examiners do not expect an encyclopaedic differential. They expect a safe, structured, prioritised one.
The Opening: Win the First 90 Seconds
Use the reading time to register the patient's age and sex — the differential for a 22-year-old is not the differential for a 72-year-old. Then:
"Hello, I'm Dr Ahmed, one of the doctors here. Can I just check your name and age? ... I can see from the notes that you've been feeling tired recently. Tell me more about that."
Then stop talking. Thirty to sixty seconds of uninterrupted listening frequently surfaces the diagnosis ("...ever since my periods got heavier") and earns interpersonal-skills marks you cannot buy back later. Only then start shaping the history.
A Five-Block Framework for Any Fatigue Station
Block 1 — Characterise the fatigue
Onset and duration — weeks versus months; abrupt (infection, giant cell arteritis) versus gradual (anaemia, hypothyroidism).
Progression — stable, worsening, fluctuating.
Functional impact — "What can't you do now that you could do six months ago?" This single question screens for anaemia, heart failure, depression and malignancy simultaneously.
Sleep quality — unrefreshing sleep with post-exertional malaise suggests chronic fatigue syndrome; snoring with daytime sleepiness suggests obstructive sleep apnoea; early-morning waking with worse mood in the mornings suggests depression.
Block 2 — A differential-directed systems screen
Work through one or two targeted questions per system. This table is your revision card:
| System | High-yield causes | The questions that find them |
|---|---|---|
| Haematological | Iron-deficiency anaemia, B12/folate deficiency | Breathlessness, palpitations, menorrhagia, vegan diet, hair loss |
| Endocrine | Hypothyroidism, diabetes, adrenal insufficiency, hypercalcaemia | Cold intolerance, weight gain, constipation; thirst and nocturia; postural dizziness and salt craving; abdominal pain and confusion |
| Cardio-respiratory | Heart failure, COPD, sleep apnoea | Orthopnoea, ankle swelling; smoking and sputum; snoring and witnessed apnoeas |
| Gastrointestinal | Coeliac disease, liver disease | Diarrhoea, bloating, weight loss, family history; jaundice, bruising, alcohol intake |
| Renal | Chronic kidney disease | Nocturia, frothy urine, NSAID use, previous renal disease |
| Infection | EBV, HIV, tuberculosis | Sore throat and nodes in a young adult; HIV risk factors (ask sensitively); night sweats, cough, weight loss, contacts and travel |
| Malignancy | Any | Red flags below |
| Psychological | Depression, anxiety, substance misuse | Two-question screen; worries, panic, alcohol and recreational drugs |
| Rheumatological | Polymyalgia rheumatica, myositis, fibromyalgia | Proximal stiffness in shoulders and hips over 50; muscle pain on statins; widespread pain with unrefreshing sleep |
| Iatrogenic | See drug table below | Full medication review, including over-the-counter and herbal remedies |
Block 3 — Red flags (never leave without them)
Unintentional weight loss
Night sweats or unexplained fever
GI blood loss — melaena, haematemesis, rectal bleeding
Change in bowel habit lasting more than six weeks
Dysphagia
New lump, lymphadenopathy or bone pain
Chest pain, breathlessness at rest or syncope
New headache with visual change or jaw claudication in a patient over 50
One or two red flags change the entire station — from routine bloods to an urgent suspected-cancer referral or same-day assessment.
Block 4 — Background: the four histories
PMH — autoimmune disease, previous malignancy, thyroid or coeliac disease.
Drugs — see the table below.
FH — coeliac disease, thyroid disease, type 1 diabetes, bowel and breast cancer.
SH — alcohol (AUDIT-C style), smoking, recreational drugs, diet, exercise, shift work, psychosocial stressors, caring responsibilities.
Two screens you cannot skip:
Depression — the two-question screen:
"Over the last month, have you often been bothered by feeling down, depressed or hopeless?"
"Over the last month, have you often been bothered by having little interest or pleasure in doing things?"
Pregnancy — in any woman of childbearing age, ask about the possibility and offer a pregnancy test before medications or imaging.
Block 5 — ICE and the closing minute
Return to ideas, concerns and expectations:
"Was there anything you were worried this might be? ... Is there anything in particular you were hoping we would do today?"
Common Drugs That Cause Fatigue
| Drug class | Examples | Mechanism / exam pearl |
|---|---|---|
| Cardiovascular | Beta-blockers, diuretics | Bradycardia; electrolyte disturbance |
| CNS | Benzodiazepines, sedating antihistamines, opioids, gabapentinoids | Sedation and falls risk |
| Endocrine | Steroids, amiodarone | Amiodarone causes hypo- or hyperthyroidism |
| GI | Long-term PPIs | B12 and magnesium deficiency |
| Oncology/rheum | Statins, methotrexate, checkpoint inhibitors | Check CK for statin myalgia; immunotherapy causes immune-related thyroiditis and adrenal insufficiency — a favourite modern twist |
Timing the Eight Minutes
| Time | Task |
|---|---|
| 0:00–0:30 | Introduction, consent, open question, listen |
| 0:30–4:30 | Blocks 1–2: characterise the fatigue and run the systems screen |
| 4:30–5:30 | Blocks 3–4: red flags, background histories, depression screen |
| 5:30–6:30 | Summarise, revisit ICE, answer the patient's questions |
| 6:30–7:30 | Explain differentials and agree the investigation plan |
| 7:30–8:00 | Safety-net, arrange follow-up, close |
What to Tell the Examiner: Investigations in Tiers
Answer in tiers — it sounds instantly senior:
Bedside: observations, urine dip, pregnancy test where relevant.
First-line bloods: FBC with ferritin, U&E, LFTs, calcium, TFT, HbA1c, CRP/ESR, coeliac serology (while still eating gluten), B12 and folate.
Targeted second-line: HIV test if risk factors, EBV serology in young patients, CK if myalgia on statins, CXR if respiratory symptoms or a smoker, sleep study if OSA suspected, ECG.
Then finish with the sentence examiners love: "I would review the patient with the results rather than leaving the loop open."
Management and Closing the Station
Summarise — "Can I just check I've understood everything so far..."
Explain the working differential in plain English — "Tiredness has many causes; the commonest are low iron, an underactive thyroid, low mood and poor sleep. Today's tests will help narrow it down."
Agree the plan — investigations plus sensible interim self-help: sleep hygiene, alcohol reduction, diet.
Safety-net — "If you develop heavy bleeding, fainting, chest pain, or you ever feel low enough to consider harming yourself, come back the same day."
Follow-up — book a review with results.
Worked Example: Same Station, Two Endings
Scenario A — Sara, 31. Six months of tiredness, heavy periods, vegan diet. The history converges on menorrhagia and diet causing iron deficiency. Examiner answer: FBC, ferritin, TFT and coeliac serology; treat the iron deficiency; investigate the menorrhagia; dietary advice; review with results.
Scenario B — Harold, 67. Six months of tiredness with unintentional weight loss and new constipation. Red flags now dominate: iron deficiency with suspected colorectal malignancy. Examiner answer: FBC and ferritin plus an urgent suspected lower-GI cancer referral; explain it sensitively without burying it in jargon.
Same framework — wildly different stations. That is exactly the point: the structure keeps you safe when the script changes.
Ten Pitfalls That Fail Fatigue Stations
Machine-gun closed questions with no opening
Forgetting the depression screen
Not offering a pregnancy test
No red-flag questions
Ignoring the medication list
"I'd do some bloods" — always name them
No safety-netting or follow-up
Over-running on one system (usually thyroid) and missing everything else
Jargon — "check your haemoglobin" not "rule out anaemia of chronic disease"
Writing while the patient is speaking instead of listening
How to Practise Before Exam Day
Run two fatigue stations per week, each with a different underlying cause.
Record yourself and count your interruptions — aim for zero in the first minute.
Drill the 30-second differential: anaemia, thyroid disease, diabetes, depression, sleep apnoea, coeliac disease, alcohol, medication side effects, and malignancy red flags — then name your top three.
Make flashcards of red flags, the fatigue drug list and the two-question depression screen.
Simulate examiner questions at the end of every practice station.
Rotate the demographics: young women, older men, shift workers, new immigrants — the differential shifts each time.
Final Thoughts
The fatigue station is not a knowledge exam — it is a structure exam. Walk in with the five-block framework, the two mandatory screens, a red-flag checklist, tiered investigations and a clear safety net, and you will convert one of the most feared presentations into one of the most reliable stations on your PLAB 2 circuit.
Join the Discussion
Share your thoughts and insights with the medical community
Comments
Delete Comment
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This action cannot be undone.